Gamernode: Columns - The right to return games for a full refund

Search
Column

The right to return games for a full refund

Category: Industry, Posted: 08/27/2007 at 05:53PM CDT by Frank Ling, Editorial Director

video gamesWhen I first started gaming, as it is with all gaming noobs, I bought a game that was a first class loser. The box said I would have the best gaming experience ever. Well, that didn't happen and I was stuck with it because the fine print on my receipt said, "No Returns on Opened Software."

So I only had one solution. Go to the used video game store to trade it in for cash or store credit.

I entered the store and saw the manager behind the counter. I know him by name. His name is Caesar. Caesar is the type of guy who thinks he knows everything about games and is always trying to impress everyone that he does. Whenever I've asked him a question, he seems annoyed that I have disturbed his environment. He doesn't ever greet anyone, nor does he smile. He just stares at you as if you have intruded into his perfect world of boredom, and in a way, you have done just that. (For the record, he was fired within the year for lecturing a kid for wanting to buy a GameShark while the mother stood and listened to him rant, "What, how are you going to be good in life if you cheat all the time!")

Never-the-less, I am on a mission to dump my horrid game unto him. I grit my teeth and offer him a greeting by saying, "Hi. I'd like to see how much credit I can get for this." He stares down at the game and says to me, "Man, this game sucks. I'll give you a $15 store credit or $12 in cash." Astounded, I plead and say, "But I paid $50 for this stinking game." "Not my problem, dude. Take it or leave it." I stare him in the eye and say, "I'll leave it," and walk out the door.

So now I've got a game that has not only made my wallet lighter by $50 plus tax, I can't do anything to get my full purchase price back. At this point, my anger is focused on the manager of the video game store. But after sulking for an hour at my bad fortune, it suddenly dawns on me that it isn't the store manager's fault, it was my own fault for not doing my research on the game before buying it. I was duped into the glossy ads and game packaging. But at the heart of all my woes was the game publisher who produced this offensive piece of trash. How could they let this kind of game reach the store shelves?

We can ask for refunds on everything, it seems, except video games. I can return a book to my book store if it's not satisfactory. I can return food from a supermarket if it's not satisfactory. I could have even returned my pet dog if I wanted to when I bought him from the breeder. (Of course I wouldn't have ever done that, Mac.) But video games? I don't even have one day to consider my purchase. Once I pay for it --  till death do us part...until I try to sell it for less than a third of my original cost.

Game publishers should be held accountable for games that suck. If we, the gamers don't have the right to return substandard games, the publishers couldn't be happier because a sale is a sale. What we need around here is a one-day return policy in this country. I know that publishers will rant about people trying to copy their software, but good software sells anyway and gamers will want to keep the good ones...not return them.

I want the right to return a game for a full refund within a reasonable amount of time to find out if it sucks. Don't you?

Posted by lskennedy on 08/30/2007 at 12:17PM

Heck yes i do. i have boughten quite a few craptacular games, for instance red steel, and no way can i return it. I hate the trade in rates for some of the games too. So hence why i am at the node all the time, checking reviews, other peoples opinions. And btw, that clerk was really getting on that kids case? he really needs help then.

Posted by bull 53 on 08/30/2007 at 08:04PM

I don't disagree with you but video games fall under the same category as music CDs and DVDs. If you happen across a total stinker, you can only return it for a new shrink wrapped copy of the same steaming pie. It is what it is. I like reviews because they serve as a guideline to me. My friends are OK but soemtimes they get caught up in the hype machine. I have found that I like a lot of things that generally are not critically acclaimed (where the review for Brunswick Pro Bowling on the Wii?). Anyway, isn't part of the definition of gamer that you live and die by your games?

Posted by Brendon on 09/12/2007 at 05:00PM

That's not entirely true, bull. I know in Portland there are at least two stores I can think of that sell DVDs and/or CDs which give you a 2 day period to bring something back in, and you can exchange it for something of equal value. When I lived in LA there was a store I knew of that did that, but it had to be within the same day.
(Of course, then you get into the issue of people selling opened things as new, but that's an entirely different topic.)
It's secluded cases, to be certain, but I have NEVER seen any gaming store offer a similar service -- even small mom and pop ones. Probably due to the much higher cost of most games than CDs and DVDs.

Posted by Viewtiful on 01/11/2008 at 11:22PM

The GameStop near me (Chicago) would let you return a game for full price within 3 days up until a couple years ago. They said that people were just buying the game and burning through it then returning it regardless of how good it was.

Posted by rtanger on 03/06/2008 at 02:19PM

I don't get why opened movies and software cannot be returned. To cut down on piracy? It doesn't make sense to me. If that was the case, then games and movie rentals shouldn't be legal either (which I'm glad they are!) If I was pirating stuff, it would seem to make much more sense to rent 5 movies, and copy them all for the same price I could buy a new one for the same purpose....unless I'm missing the point.

It seems now that buying a game is a commitment- if it sucks, too bad. The only exchange you can get damn near anywhere is for another copy of the same title.

Posted by NavMan on 03/07/2008 at 07:09AM

EB games here has a 7 day return policy if you're not satisfied. As long as the disc works and is good condition with all the packaging and booklets.

Posted by Sersoft.corp on 05/25/2008 at 02:04PM

Lol a guy who works at EBgames always calls me a fucking retard for no reason at all, and nobody cares.

Post a Comment

Please login or sign up as a GamerNode member to post a comment.