Crave Online » Gaming » GamerNode

Gamernode: News - Killzone 2 wins "Dumbest AI" award

Search
News

Killzone 2 wins "Dumbest AI" award

Category: PlayStation 3, Posted: 09/08/2007 at 10:39AM CDT by Brian Schulman, GN Content Contributor

Oh man, I'm just stoking the fanboy fires with this one. Still, the question needed to be asked. Why? In their October issue EGM awarded Halo 3 Smartest AI, while Killzone 2 earned the dubious distinction of having the Dumbest AI.

Now, I've played neither and thus have no reason to question their judgement (at least anymore than usual), but the fact that best and worst were awarded to both flagship FPS's for either console is bound to have spawned plenty of fanboy hatred.

Of course, that's what happened. In a blog post, Dan Hsu, EGM editor, responded to allegations of bias:

But there's gotta be some other, lesser-profile games with worse A.I. than Killzone 2. - Based on what we've seen and what we voted on, totally fairly, Killzone 2 nabbed the award. Part of the problem is, the Killzone 2 showed some very noticeable flaws. It wasn't like the enemies were just standing around. Like we mentioned in the write-up, the bad guys were actually jumping out of cover to get *in* the line of fire. It's like they wanted to get shot. That alone, unfortunately, made Killzone 2 look worse (A.I.-wise) than it probably is.

Plus, these awards aren't that big of a deal, people. They were laughing at one example of weirdness on display, that doesn't mean that they hate the company you're strangely obsessed with.

Posted by Dr.Aaron on 09/08/2007 at 10:54AM

I don't get how halo 3 can get best ai when noones reviewed the single player portion yet...?
And answer to killzone= pre-alpha, easy mode etc

Posted by Archem on 09/08/2007 at 11:27AM

What organization gave these awards now? Perhaps it's because I just recently woke up, but I can't find out anywhere in this article exactly WHO presented these AI-based awards.

Posted by Brendon on 09/08/2007 at 12:41PM

"In their October issue EGM awarded..."

Posted by Quasar on 09/08/2007 at 01:11PM

EGM (Electronic Game Monthly) has been around for a long time and their reviews (IMO) are probably the most biased and unfair in the industry. So being caught with their pants down over this AI thing is expected. I'm just surprised that they haven't been caught more often with stuff like this.

Posted by 7ty714 on 09/10/2007 at 10:10AM

I'm pretty sure a lot of upcoming games (Project Origin among them, the sequel to FEAR which was among other things universally praised for its amazing AI) will have miles better AI than Halo 3. I didn't even know anyone had previewed the Single Player of Halo 3? >_> And if I recall correctly, Halo 1 and 2's AI weren't very exemplary. EGM are idiots.

Post a Comment

Please login or sign up as a GamerNode member to post a comment.